IndianaLocalNews

Man who killed workers at Papa John’s, sentenced for murder

(Photo supplied/Elkhart County Jail)
The man who killed a couple who worked at the Papa John’s on Cassopolis Street in Elkhart, back in February, has been sentenced for two counts of murder.
Jose Benitez Tilley Jr. will spend 65 years in prison for killing Haley Smith and 65 years for killing Dustin Carr, but the sentenced will be served at the same time.
A witness told investigators Tilley used to work at Papa John’s and they had issues with him in the past. The witness said the suspect had been at the restaurant prior to the killings, asking for a job.
Tilley admitted to the murders and also trying to rape Smith after killing her.
A charge of abuse of a corpse was dropped as part of the plea.

Related posts

Cass County residents prepare to act on future data center proposals

Jon Zimney

Bridge work to begin at Indiana Toll Road overpass

Alyssa Foster

Northern Indiana woman accused of murdering father, cutting out heart

Network Indiana

1 comment

Adam July 17, 2022 at 10:55 am

This evil Criminal should have gotten the death penalty instead. Let’s hope he is never released to walk the streets again.

Reply

Leave a Comment