Indiana Supreme Court refuses to hear Alyssa Shepherd appeal

(Photo supplied/Indiana State Police)

Alyssa Shepherd stays in prison for now. The Indiana Supreme Court will not hear her appeal.

Shepherd, 26, is serving four years in prison for hitting four children and killing three of them when she sped past a school bus with its stop arm extended on Oct. 30, 2018, in Fulton County.

Shepherd’s lawyers argued that the state did not prove beyond a reasonable doubt that she was driving recklessly when she hit and killed Aliva Stahl, 9, and twin brothers Xavier and Mason Ingle. Her truck also hit a fourth child who survived, but with severe injuries.

The court left the felony convictions of reckless homicide and criminal recklessness intact, but threw out the misdemeanor conviction of reckless driving.

Shepherd’s lawyers attempted to get her felony convictions thrown out on technicalities related to instructions to the jury. That argument was rejected.

Related posts

Delphi judge denies more media broadcast rights for May trial

Network Indiana

Indiana USPS locations to host job fairs to fill immediate openings

95.3 MNC

YMCA of Greater Michiana to begin operations for new downtown South Bend facility

95.3 MNC


Brad December 22, 2020 at 8:38 am

Good!! Do your time, and shut up. You killed three innocent babies, you don’t deserve to get out of jail.

Susanna Sweet December 29, 2020 at 1:50 am

What she deserves is more time ! I lost all faith in the Justice system after her only getting 4 years unbelievable.

Tina March 12, 2021 at 8:43 am

It was a terrible accident… Thats all…Its not like she was a drunk driver or on her phone. People need to get over it. No one was at fault.


Leave a Comment