Different visions for Indiana displayed by candidates in first gubernatorial debate

(Photo supplied)

The governor has the power to restrict your movements and make you wear a mask, says the governor. Incumbent Republican Eric Holcomb, Democratic candidate Dr. Woody Myers and Libertarian Donald Rainwater answered questions about education, the economy, guns and the powers of government, especially during a pandemic, in the first debate for the candidates, Monday night.

“I’d leave the court battles for later. Let’s do what we can do right now to protect our citizens from this virus, until we have a safe and effective vaccine,” said Dr. Woody Myers, when asked about governmental powers and the pandemic. The former state health commissioner was not shy in expressing his desire for more restrictions.

“I’m gonna make sure that they’re (vaccine doses) are distributed effectively and safely throughout the state of Indiana and then we can begin to consider relaxing some of the requirements that I will put in place immediately.”

One of those requirements is a mask mandate, with consequences. Myers said he is confident that a Biden/Harris administration would appoint a new head of the CDC and FDA, and he would wait on their recommendations on a vaccine to take action.

Rainwater said he believes the government has no place in telling anyone they have to wear a mask.

“Only you can determine what risk you’re willing to take and what appropriate measures that you need to take for yourself, your family, your business, your church,” he said, adding that it’s government’s job to provide you with the appropriate info to make decisions.

Both Holcomb and Myers compared to the mask mandate to being required to wear a seatbelt or not smoke in public places.

Holcomb, criticized for weilding what some people consider too much power during the pandemic, said he will be happy to sit down with the legislature in January to discuss it. Holcomb repeatedly complimented state lawmakers for having “infinite wisdom” in granting him those powers years ago.

That drew a rebuke from Rainwater.

“The members of the general assembly are human beings. They don’t have infinite wisdom. And, in my opinion the extension of powers to the governor has been a mistake,” he said.

The candidates also answered questions about teacher pay. Myers stated twice that he will appoint state Superintendent of Education Dr. Jennifer McCormick, a Republican who has publicly supported Myers, as his secretary of education. He also said he believes the answer to increasing teacher pay is a closer examination of the state budget, to prioritize education.

Holcomb pointed out that more than half of the budget goes to educating young Hoosiers.

Rainwater suggested decentralizing education and turning the money over to the local school boards, saving dollars spent on state bureaucracy, which could go to pay teachers more.

“There is no such thing as state money. There is no such thing as public money. That is tax dollars that Hoosiers have been paying that are supposed to go to the education of a child,” he said.

The three also differed on the ability to carry a firearm without a license. Myers opposes it outright.

“We’ve got to understand that guns kill people,” he said. “The 2nd Amendment is gonna survive just fine without more individuals carrying more weapons around, brandishing them and scaring members of the public.”

That statement drew a correction from Rainwater, who pointed out that carrying is not brandishing and that brandishing is illegal.

Myers said he supports strict background checks, while Holcomb did not say he would support getting a consitutional carry bill passed, saying a five-year free license has made it easy to own a gun for hunting or defense.

Rainwater said he is for fewer restrictions on gun ownership, and that owning them means the ability to defend oneself from crooks or big government.

The next debate, put together by the Indiana Debate Commission, is Tues., Oct. 27, at 7 p.m. You can hear the debate, live, on 95.3 FM and

Related posts

South Bend woman to prison, ordered to pay over half a million dollars for embezzlement

Jon Zimney

Indiana State Fair to add events, attractions to 2024 fair’s lineup

Alyssa Foster

Elkhart Schools impacted by tornado, offering additional food service sites

Jon Zimney


CHRISTOPHER HALL October 21, 2020 at 1:21 pm

Rainwater all the way!

Slacker06 October 21, 2020 at 3:21 pm

According to no lesser light than Thomas Jefferson as penned in the 2nd Paragraph of the Declaration of Independence, the prime responsibility of government, in fact the very reason for it’s existence, is to SECURE RIGHTS. Do not support a single politician, including two of these stooges, that does not forthrightly secure the rights of The People in all they do under color of government. Mask mandates do not do this. I’m not a ghoul because of my mask decisions. You can only be responsible for yourself and those in your immediate household. Contrary to the mantra of the Hildebeest, it does not take a village. It takes individual liberty and being responsible for your own actions. More firearms restriction do not secure rights. Guns all by them selves do not kill people. People using guns for illegal activity kill people. None of the gang-bangers killing in the streets of Indy or Chicago own or carry their firearms legally. No person licensed to carry a firearm routinely goes about killing and breaking the law. Not a single one of them bothered to pass a background check before taking illegal possession of the tools of their trade. More guns means less crime not more crime. Vote for the candidate that will secure rights rather than the stooge that will take your rights on any pretext. Rights were given by God. They are part of our humanity. That is referred to by our founders ans Natural Law. No government official all on his own has any right to take rights away from us especially by executive order.. Government did not give any right. Government can only SECURE RIGHTS previously given by God. It is very sad to see a candidate promise more of the same, or worse. It is sad to see the incumbent seemly be pleased with himself for restricting the liberty of The People.

H October 21, 2020 at 3:47 pm

Sad fact is rainwater won’t win. I want him to but he won’t. A vote for rainwater sadly is vote for Myers. If I can’t have Rainwater i’d rather have Holcomb

Chris October 22, 2020 at 12:35 pm

So right Slacker! Not only is pleased with himself he tried to convey non-mask wearers are infringing on the Liberties of the mask wears. Totally comfortable with his mandate restricting the Liberties of all of us. What a twisted way of looking at things. Agree the Dem’s words are even worse but I can not, in good conscience vote for Holcomb again. Rainwater has my vote.

Charles U Farley October 26, 2020 at 9:50 am

The Dems words are even worse, but a vote for Rainwater is a vote for Myers.

By not voting for Holcomb, you quite literally risk ending up with the worst option of the 3.


Leave a Comment