IndianaLocalNews

Goshen man accused of killing an engaged couple has signed a plea deal

(Photo supplied/Elkhart County Jail)

A Goshen man accused of killing an engaged couple has signed a plea deal.

Officials say the shooting happened on February 12, during the closing shift at Papa John’s in Elkhart.

The Elkhart Truth reports that 20-year-old Jose Benitez-Tilley says he shot and killed 22-year-old Hayley Smith and 37-year-old Dustin Carr.

Benitez-Tilley entered the plea deal on Thursday.

The deal sets a 65 year sentence for each count of murder, to be served at one time.

His sentencing is set for July 14.

He awaits a jury trial on August 1.

You can go here for the original story from The Elkhart Truth.

Related posts

Elkhart County Miracle likely out for 2026 season After Northern League loses stadium lease

Jon Zimney

Police: Alcohol may be factor in crash on U.S. 12 in Cass County

Jon Zimney

Indiana State Police trooper shot, suspect dead in northwest Indiana

Network Indiana

1 comment

Adam June 18, 2022 at 5:09 am

He should have gotten the death penalty for this horrible crime and taking innocent lives.

Reply

Leave a Comment